Colorado Doubles State Tax Rate. Is Michigan Next?

On Election Day, Colorado passed a misguided ballot measure to nearly double the state's top tax rate from 4.4% to 8.4%. Will Michigan follow suit in 2028 with a dramatic tax hike of its own?

Michigan Democrats, who are about to control the governorship and both state houses, are looking for new revenue to fill their budget shortfall and fund their big-government priorities. Incoming Gov. Jocelyn Benson and incoming Democrat House Speaker Ranjeev Puri have called for new revenue sources, i.e., tax hikes. Benson embarrassingly didn't know the state's current income tax rate in an August interview but nonetheless suggested it is too low.

Benson has also promised not to raise taxes on the middle class. But Michigan Democrats lack the two-thirds support in Lansing needed to change the constitution and create a graduated tax rate system. Michigan's fair, economically competitive, and constitutionally protected flat tax is the last safeguard preventing Michigan from becoming a tax-and-spend state.

Enter the San Francisco dark-money-group-funded Invest in MI Kids, which has promised to begin gathering signatures in 2027 for a 2028 ballot measure to change the constitutional tax code and more than double Michigan's top marginal tax rate from 4.25% to 9.25% via a simple majority of voters.

The new levy would apply to those who earn at least $500,000 a year, including small businesses, families, farmers, and ordinary folks who sell their home at a significant capital gain. (Invest in MI Kids is reportedly also considering other tax-hike provisions, including raising state corporate and sales taxes.)

The activists’ income tax hike campaign failed to qualify for the 2026 ballot because it didn't collect enough signatures. But this time around, it will get a big boost from state Democrats, who see this ballot measure as the vehicle to significantly raise taxes and grow government at the expense of the real economy.

Doubling the state's top tax rate is terrible policy, as Colorado is about to find out. High state taxes drive out businesses, jobs, families, and economic opportunity. Just look at New York State versus Florida, Illinois versus Tennessee, or California versus Texas for proof. As a result, these tax hikes raise way less tax revenue than they promise.

Consider Massachusetts, which raised its top state tax rate from 5% to 9% via ballot measure in 2022. As a result, the Bay State has one of the nation's highest levels of outmigration and capital flight.

A Boston Globe poll finds one in three residents has considered leaving within the last year. According to IRS data, the state lost $4.2 billion in income in 2023, with successful job creators accounting for 70% of the outflow. As a result, Massachusetts ranks among the worst in the nation for job growth. It is one of only three states whose private-sector employment hasn't returned to pre-COVID levels. (Michigan itself has only barely recovered.)

Michigan's economy has already been weakened by bad state and federal policies. It would be crushed by a similar tax hike on its most productive residents. A 9.25% tax rate, the seventh-highest in the nation, would chase economic activity across the border to tax-friendly Indiana and contribute to the growing number of empty storefronts and "for lease" signs in Grand Rapids, Lansing, and Detroit.

Many Michiganders work for decades to make $500,000 from their business, farm, or employer, and only stay in this tax bracket for a year or two. They are not "the rich." They'd offset surging tax costs by reducing job opportunities, wages, spending, and investment.

Activists ignore these consequences and claim more tax revenue is needed for education. It’s “for the children.”

But as a recent Great Lakes Policy Institute report drawing on state fiscal and school data pointed out, Michigan’s combined education funding per student nearly doubled between 2011/12 and 2025/26, rising from $8,500 to $16,000. At the same time, test scores plummeted to 44th nationally in fourth-grade reading.

In other words, Michigan education is funded enough already. And funding doesn't correlate with results.

Following in the footsteps of Colorado, Massachusetts, and other high-tax states would be all pain, no gain for Michigan.

But can ordinary Michigan residents contend with tax-hungry politicians, bureaucrats, and activists who demagogue the issue and have essentially unlimited funds from the George Soros-backed Tides Foundation?

Michigan's small business supporters need to start fighting now to save the state's economy before ballot measure signature gathering begins in 2027. Not three months prior to Election Day 2028, when it will be too late.

Next
Next

Michigan's Tax Hike Ballot Measure Defeated For Now